Updated UK buying guide
Best Bathroom Scales UK: Apps, Shared Use & Daily Routine
By Tim McGregor · Updated 11 September 2026
For smart scales, the app you want to use and the people sharing the scale are central choices. A long list of body metrics is not evidence that one device measures more accurately than another.
Research-based comparison using manufacturer information checked 11 September 2026. We have not personally tested these products. Recommendations are editorial judgements about their published differences.
Quick answer
- Withings Body Smart: for a Withings routine.
- Eufy Smart Scale P3: for detailed app readouts.
- Garmin Index S2 Smart Scale: for Garmin Connect users.
For smart scales, the app you want to use and the people sharing the scale are central choices. A long list of body metrics is not evidence that one device measures more accurately than another.
Top 3 bathroom scales compared
Choose by the job and trade-offs below. Amazon links open product searches: confirm the exact model, bundle and seller on the selected offer.
Withings Body Smart
Withings Body Smart makes sense to investigate if you want to keep your weight history in the Withings app. Its listed support for eight users is relevant to a shared household.
Benefits & things to consider
Consider it if
You want a Withings-based history and household profiles.
Main compromise
App and phone compatibility need checking before purchase.
Before ordering
Check current phone requirements and how each person sets up their profile.
Manufacturer reference · checked 11 September 2026.
Check latest price on Amazon Explore this product ↗
Eufy Smart Scale P3
Eufy Smart Scale P3 advertises sixteen metrics. Consider whether those readouts are useful to you; their number does not establish accuracy or make them a medical assessment.
Benefits & things to consider
Consider it if
You prefer Eufy’s app presentation and will use its trend history.
Main compromise
More displayed metrics can add information you do not need.
Before ordering
Review the app, account requirements and model T9150 before buying.
Manufacturer reference · checked 11 September 2026.
Check latest price on Amazon Explore this product ↗
Garmin Index S2 Smart Scale
Garmin Index S2 is the natural option to investigate if Garmin Connect is already where you review your activity. Its published sixteen-user support also suits comparing household-profile arrangements.
Benefits & things to consider
Consider it if
You already use Garmin Connect and want weight history there.
Main compromise
It is less compelling if you do not want another Garmin account or app routine.
Before ordering
Check setup requirements and how the scale identifies household users.
Manufacturer reference · checked 11 September 2026.
Check latest price on Amazon Explore this product ↗How we chose these bathroom scales
We compared the published differences that affect the buying decisions explained below: which app do you want to keep using; plan household profiles and privacy; what can this comparison say about accuracy.
This is a focused shortlist, not an exhaustive market test. We have not measured performance or long-term reliability. The manufacturer references support specifications; our reasons to consider each product are editorial interpretations. Prices and availability depend on the selected retailer offer.
At a glance
| Product | Specification or model check | Consider it if | Compromise |
|---|---|---|---|
| Withings Body Smart | Body Smart · Wi-Fi synchronisation · Up to 8 users | You want a Withings-based history and household profiles. | App and phone compatibility need checking before purchase. |
| Eufy Smart Scale P3 | Smart Scale P3 · T9150 family · 16 advertised metrics | You prefer Eufy’s app presentation and will use its trend history. | More displayed metrics can add information you do not need. |
| Garmin Index S2 Smart Scale | Index S2 · Wi-Fi synchronisation · Up to 16 users | You already use Garmin Connect and want weight history there. | It is less compelling if you do not want another Garmin account or app routine. |
What to check before buying
- Withings Body Smart: Check current phone requirements and how each person sets up their profile.
- Eufy Smart Scale P3: Review the app, account requirements and model T9150 before buying.
- Garmin Index S2 Smart Scale: Check setup requirements and how the scale identifies household users.
Related comparisons
You may also want to compare our guides to the best electric toothbrushes , best shower heads . You can also browse the full Bathroom category.
How to choose bathroom scales
Which app do you want to keep using?
Look at the app before choosing the scale. Consider whether you can easily find the history you care about, which features require an account and whether any optional services have charges. If you only want a weight readout, ask whether you need a connected model at all.
Plan household profiles and privacy
Check how each person creates an account and how readings are assigned. Do not assume every metric is visible to every household member, or that privacy settings are identical across brands. Read the current account and data-sharing controls before linking another service.
What can this comparison say about accuracy?
We have not tested these scales against reference equipment. Body-composition readouts are estimates and should not be treated as a diagnosis. Follow the exact manual for positioning, measurement conditions and any restrictions on using its body-composition functions; compare trends cautiously rather than treating one reading as a verdict.
Specifications and care sources
- Withings Body Smart — manufacturer information
- Eufy Smart Scale P3 — manufacturer information
- Garmin Index S2 Smart Scale — manufacturer information
Manufacturer information checked 11 September 2026. Follow the instructions supplied with your exact product; regional versions and bundles can differ.
Final verdict
For smart scales, the app you want to use and the people sharing the scale are central choices. A long list of body metrics is not evidence that one device measures more accurately than another.
Use the shortlist to narrow your choice, then confirm the specific model and its main compromise in the table before ordering. A higher specification is useful only when it serves your routine.
Frequently asked questions
Does a scale with more metrics have better accuracy?
Not necessarily. Metric count is a feature list. We have not carried out independent accuracy testing on these scales.
Which model connects to Garmin Connect?
Garmin Index S2 is designed to synchronise over Wi-Fi with Garmin Connect. Confirm current setup and account requirements.
Have you personally tested these bathroom scales?
No. We researched published manufacturer information on 11 September 2026. We do not claim hands-on performance or durability testing.
Do the Amazon links open an exact product listing?
They open product searches. Results can include other models, bundles and sellers. Confirm the full model name and included items before ordering.